Outside the Box

Macro-EU: The Solution Illusion

June 5, 2012

Nobody, in my book, slices and dices data more thoroughly or convincingly than Greg Weldon. In this week's Outside the Box, he first dispels the illusion that either of the two most-expected outcomes of the growing eurozone crisis is really any kind of a solution – neither expelling Greece nor keeping Greece in the club is going to work, he argues – and then, in a feat of legerdemain, he conjures up an alternative that just might work – and backs up his idea as only Greg can. But is this a rabbit he's pulled out of his hat, or is it ... a Black Eagle?

This letter will print a little longer but, as is usual with Greg, it's chock full of great charts. You can learn more about his work at www.weldononline.com. For institutions and hedge funds, it should be required reading. (It is a little more than your average service, but as you can see, he really gets into the data very deeply!)

I am in Philadelphia tonight to speak for Steve Blumenthal's Advisor Forum. We did an evening at the National Constitution Center museum, where they had a Bruce Springsteen exhibit on the first floor and rather fascinating historical display of the history of the US and the Constitution. At the end is a room where there are 39 bronze life-sized statues of the men who were at the Constitutional Convention, displayed as they might have been arrayed at the signing. It got me to thinking about the times. Indeed, there was a quote from Washington about how bad things had become in 1789, sounding much like so many who now see the US as a hopeless culture, careening down a path of socialism and entropy. And certainly, the US and much of the world face some very hard choices in the next year or so; but somehow I think we will do just fine, even if we make a few bad choices and have to correct our course more than we would like.

Of course, it helps to have a Washington, Hamilton, Franklin, Adams, Madison, and Jefferson to help guide the ship on its course, but we will have to make do with what we have. Every country needs leaders with a clear vision and a love of posterity. Maybe later generations will recognize leadership where we do not. Here's hoping.

On Wednesday I get to spend much of the day with David Rosenberg, and I am sure we will go over our own poor vision of what will happen. And Thursday I get to have lunch with George and Meredith Friedman of Stratfor, in Austin, where I will listen as he gives me his latest take on the world. I always come away from my time with them with a whole lot more insight. Then it's a few afternoon meetings and on to the University of Texas for a seminar with Rosie and Rich Yamarone (with whom I had lunch yesterday in New York). It will be fun.

Your trying to get a whole lot done in a short amount of time analyst,

John Mauldin, Editor
Outside the Box

Like Outside the Box?

Then you'll love John's premium publication, Over My Shoulder. Each week, after sorting through vast amounts of economic, political, and investing news, John sends Over My Shoulder subscribers his pick of the week's most important commentary and data.

It's your opportunity to get the news John thinks matters most to your finances.

Learn More About Over My Shoulder


Macro-EU: The Solution Illusion

Weldon's Money Monitor

May 23, 2012

Dating all the way back to the day the Greek Drachma was accepted into the EU's ERM (Exchange Rate Mechanism), thus retiring Greece's currency, and replacing it with the Eurocurrency ... we have always believed that a two-tier Eurocurrency 'regime' would ultimately 'reign', once the EUR experiment failed.

We envisioned that the northern 'core' countries such as Germany, France, the Netherlands, Belgium and Austria…

Discuss This

4 comments

We welcome your comments. Please comply with our Community Rules.

Comments

David Oldham

June 6, 2012, 1:27 p.m.

I don’t think this is a new idea, I feel sure I have read this option proposed at least a year or two ago (perhaps in the UK press). I think we are now all brain dead on the ezone farce. They have us travelling in ever decreasing circles the idea being that we all implode together. There must be a good black hole lurking somewhere for all our unsustainable debt.

Alan Harris

June 5, 2012, 1:05 p.m.

Why is everyone making this so complicated? There isn’t just one solution….there are many, but money makes the world go round, so the final solution will be market dictated.
German industry has historically prospered by averaging the value of the Euro, while the feudal southern countries have been outpriced to uncompetitive redundancy (BRICS luvin it).
Germany will NOT evict Greece etc…its not in their interests. They will continue to kick the can for as long as possible while insisting on others’ austerity and use the inevitable non-compliance to justify withholding any more debt/money. Greece etc cannot comply forever, short of virtual slavery for 2+ generations, so they will elect to leave…..political honours drawn.
But now Germany et al have got a REAL problem !! The euro will strengthen and increase in value meaning their exports get much more expensive…..Germany, and all the remainder, now unable to sell BMW’s for twice the price, so fall into recession. Even more countries leave and each translates their euro debt into devalued local currency. Endgame….Germany ends up skint, while southern europe gets off the hook and achieves stability.
People ALWAYS survive. Don’t confuse the value of a loaf of bread, a bottle of local vino and a day out at the seaside with the kids, with the tragedy of someone else’s devalued paper money. When you’ve got nothing, you’ve got nothing to lose.
Tip: when it happens, put cheap Greek/Irish/Spanish/etc equities into your retirement fund, wait for the bounce and join them on the beach. A much better use of your time than pouring over acres of laughable graphs.

Robert Watkins

June 5, 2012, 11:24 a.m.

If JM was correct a few months back, if and when Germany leaves the Euro their currency would appreciate greatly making their exports very expensive. Which ever route the Euro takes, Germany is in for a great deal of pain!

If I were a German taxpayer,  I’d much rather take my chances on a strong currency rather than bailing out 50 year old retirees who refuse to cut spending! At least those Germans who have any form of savings will not be faced with hyper inflation from printing massive amounts of Euro to bail out those who have borrowed and spent themselves into bankruptcy!

Paul Weaver

June 5, 2012, 9:21 a.m.

Europe first came together under the power of Rome When Rome fell Europe, first as city states, then as countries, went to war. They fought with themselves and outsiders ending in the last two world wars. The idea of the EU was formost to try to stop this happening again. Single monetary union was not going to work without political union - more war or breakup?
The two faces looking left?  We need one looking Right!
Paul Weaver, UK