How to Survive the Obamacare Collapse
- Patrick Watson
- Connecting the Dots
- March 28, 2017
President Trump is right when he says the Affordable Care Act will collapse on its own. Its condition is terminal, and Congress declined treatment last week.
Maybe that’s no big deal to you. Maybe you’re on Medicare, or get group health coverage from your employer, or are independently wealthy, or you’re in good health and confident you will remain so.
Unfortunately, millions of Americans who don’t fall into any of those categories may soon find themselves in a tough spot.
I don’t want that to be you, so today I’m sounding the alarm. You may enter 2018 with no access to health insurance, which means you will be at risk both medically and financially.
Now is the time to prepare.
Money for Nothing
The first step to solving a problem is admitting you have one. Some of us are in denial, so here’s a hard fact:
We Americans spend far more money on healthcare than any other developed nation, but we’re no healthier.
We’re even less healthy overall.
Like what you're reading?
The chart below shows the bad news. The horizontal axis is years of life expectancy. The vertical axis is per capita healthcare spending.
Ideally, you want to be in the lower right quadrant. That means your population has a relatively high life expectancy and relatively low healthcare spending.
France, Japan, Spain, Chile, and a bunch of others are clustered in that area. Their money buys more health than ours does.
Image: Financial Times
The United States is in the upper right, which shows that our per-person healthcare spending is significantly higher than that of the other OECD countries. Switzerland is a distant second place.
Our extra spending doesn’t help us live longer. We actually die a little earlier than our peers in Japan and most of Europe.
You can quibble over details in this data, but the broad facts are inescapable. We spend too much on healthcare relative to the health it buys us. As long as that is the case, no reform plan will work.
Did Obamacare cause this? No. It goes way back. Here’s another graphic showing the changes over time.
Image: Our World in Data
You can see that the United States began diverging from other developed countries back in the 1980s. The gap has only grown wider since then.
Stranger yet, we spend all this extra money yet still leave millions of low-income citizens with little or no access to healthcare. Kaiser Family Foundation says some 2.5 million working Americans make too much to qualify for Medicaid, but not enough to receive Obamacare tax credits.
Death Spiral Approaching
I showed you that data to say this: Simply returning to pre-Obamacare conditions won’t solve the problem. Obamacare exists because the system wasn’t working and we needed something better.
Like what you're reading?
Before 2014, people with preexisting conditions were simply out of luck. They couldn’t buy health insurance at any price, unless their employers offered group health, which many didn’t. This was hurting both those people and the economy at large.
Obamacare, for all its flaws, at least tried to solve the problem. It helped some people but hurt others—and now it’s reached its limits.
Insurance works only if the risk pool includes enough low-spending people to offset those with expensive claims. That’s Obamacare’s core problem. The legal mandate to buy insurance hasn’t brought enough young and healthy people into the pool.
The private insurers that participate in the Obamacare marketplaces are not in the business of losing money. They can and will back out if they see no profit potential or, worse, a risk of huge losses.
Here’s what healthcare policy expert Robert Laszewski said after the GOP proposal failed last week. Note the key point I bolded.
Now, the president has threatened to skip fixing Obamacare and let it fail. He will get his wish. The Obamacare insurance exchanges are simply unsustainable in their present form. With only 40 percent of the subsidy eligible signing up after three years, the risk pool is nowhere near the goal of getting 75 percent to sign up to assure enough healthy people are paying into the program to cover the costs of the sick.
Health insurers that I have talked to are already working on their contingency plans for 2018 should Obamacare not be repaired. Things are so unsustainable that the shrinking number of health insurance companies left in the Obamacare market are giving serious thought to whether or not they will even participate, and if they do just how much higher—and they will have to be much higher—to set the rates.
Already in 2017, one-third of US counties have only one participating marketplace insurer. More of the country will be in that position next year. Some areas may have no insurers at all, or if they do, it will likely be at higher rates for worse coverage.
This is the “death spiral” you hear about. People with serious illnesses will buy insurance no matter what it costs. This drives up claim ratios, which then drives premiums yet higher and discourages young and healthy people from buying. That can’t work indefinitely.
What to Do Now
If Laszewski is right, at least some of the millions who rely on Obamacare for health insurance will be out of luck next year.
Congress and President Trump might buy us another year or two if they put their heads together, but it seems unlikely. They might even make it worse… even though it’s going to get worse without any help.
This isn’t just a “tail risk,” as traders might call it. The odds that catastrophe will strike you may not be 100%, but they’re well above zero. We all need to get ready.
Like what you're reading?
What can you do?
- If you have insurance now and you’ve delayed treating a medical problem, don’t wait any longer. Talk to your doctor and deal with it before 2017 ends.
- Find a good insurance agent in your area. As of now, at least, some companies still sell short-term medical policies with limited coverage. An agent can help you find the best fit. They may not cover preexisting conditions, but may also be better than nothing.
- If you take expensive prescriptions, start refilling them as soon as your insurer allows. Usually, they give you a few days’ leeway before your supply runs out. Do it every time, and over a few months you’ll accumulate an extra supply.
- Take care of your body: Lose weight, eat better, get exercise—you know the drill. It will pay off financially by reducing your risk of expensive problems.
- If you work for a small business that might drop its healthcare plan, or your employment is otherwise unstable, start thinking about possible career changes now.
Another option: the religious healthcare cost-sharing plans. They aren’t “insurance” and don’t cover everything, but they count as meeting the Obamacare mandate. Look here or here to learn more.
Healthcare shouldn’t be this giant problem. The United States is a wealthy nation. We have a long tradition of helping our neighbors when misfortune strikes. But for whatever reasons, it’s turned into a political fight.
I believe that next year, millions of Americans will lose access to health insurance. It will be even worse for some—maybe you, maybe me. We don’t know where lightning will strike.
There are practical things we can all do to prepare for this. I listed a few ideas above. You may have different or better ones. I’d like to tell other readers about them, so please leave a comment below or send me an e-mail. I’ll share the best ideas in a future letter.
If the folks in Washington can’t get their act together, we’ll just have to do it ourselves.
See you at the top,
Like what you're reading?
P.S. If you’re reading this because someone shared it with you, click here to get your own free Connecting the Dots subscription. You can also follow me on Twitter: @PatrickW.
P.S. If you like my letters, you’ll love reading Over My Shoulder with serious economic analysis from my global network, at a surprisingly affordable price. Click here to learn more.